Buying a Competitor: How to Value their Business
Buying a competitor business can accelerate your growth faster than any marketing campaign or new product launch. But without careful evaluation, it can also derail your momentum and burn capital.
Whether you’re looking to expand your market share, eliminate competition, or acquire new capabilities, success depends on how well you assess the opportunity. The best acquisitions strengthen your existing engine; the wrong ones create operational headaches.
This guide breaks down the key areas to evaluate before buying a competitor’s business and covers how to identify synergies, how to build a valuation, post-sale integration planning, determining culture fit, and what red flags to avoid.
Navigate Your Exit with Confidence 🚀
Introducing the Exit Navigator
Whether you're 12 months or 12 weeks from exit, our Exit Navigator gives you a step-by-step roadmap to prepare, position, and sell your tech company at maximum value. Built for founders in the $2M–$20M revenue range, this free download includes:
A deal-readiness checklist
Tips for reducing diligence friction
Red-flag risk items buyers spot quickly
Valuation drivers by business model
A 6-phase roadmap from prep to post-close
Make your exit a strategy—not a scramble.
Book your free assessment call HERE or download our Million Dollar Exit Guide for free below 👇
1. Identify the Right Synergies
Synergies are the backbone of a smart acquisition. They’re the efficiencies or growth opportunities that make the combined business more valuable than the two companies operating separately. For strategic buyers, synergies are what separate a market price deal from a value-creating one.
Here’s how to categorize them:
When modeling synergies, focus on what’s provable, not theoretical. Overestimated synergies are the number one reason small and mid-market deals underperform.
For strategic buyers, cost synergies often have the greatest immediate impact—and that impact directly changes how you value the business.
2. Build a Valuation Grounded in Reality
Valuing a competitor isn’t just about applying a multiple to EBITDA. You’re buying more than financial performance—you’re buying market position, people, and processes.
Steps to build a sound valuation:
Normalize earnings: Adjust for owner salaries, one-time costs, and personal expenses.
Account for overlap: Remove duplicated revenue or customers that will disappear after closing.
Apply the right multiple: Use industry comps and risk factors. Similar-sized competitors often trade at 3–6x EBITDA, depending on margins, stability, and growth.
Run sensitivity tests: Model best-case and worst-case outcomes to understand risk-adjusted value.
💡 Tip: If the deal only works at an optimistic multiple, it’s not a good deal.
Example: Reframing Valuation Through Synergies
A competitor is generating $5M in revenue and $1M in EBITDA, with an asking price of 4x EBITDA ($4M).
That’s the market price for a financial buyer.
But you already have leadership, accounting, HR, systems, and a facility in place. You can absorb their operations and cut redundant costs.
You’ve just increased EBITDA by 50% through cost savings alone.
Now, instead of paying 4x for $1M of EBITDA, you’re effectively paying 2.6x EBITDA for the same business ($4M ÷ $1.5M).
That difference—$1.5M of earnings versus $1M—is your built-in value creation.
Enterprise Value Impact
Those additional profits don’t just improve the target company—they also increase your overall enterprise value.
If your existing business trades at a 5x multiple, adding $500K in EBITDA adds roughly $2.5M in value ($500K × 5).
So by acquiring a $4M business, you’ve effectively increased your combined enterprise value by over half the purchase price—before even growing revenue.
That’s the leverage of a well-modeled acquisition
Steps to Build a Sound Valuation
Normalize earnings: Adjust for owner salaries, one-time costs, and personal expenses.
Identify overlap: Quantify cost reductions from redundant roles, facilities, or systems.
Apply realistic multiples: Research industry comps—typically 3–6x EBITDA for mid-market service businesses.
Run a pro forma P&L: Model post-acquisition performance, including conservative synergy assumptions.
Calculate effective multiple: Divide the purchase price by your pro forma EBITDA to determine your real valuation.
💡 Tip: If the deal only works at an optimistic multiple, it’s not a good deal. But if the deal works better because of your existing infrastructure, it might be a great one.
3. Plan Integration Before the Ink Dries
Integration is where acquisitions live or die. Most failed deals don’t crumble during due diligence—they fall apart afterward.
Before closing, answer these questions:
Who’s leading the integration process?
Which systems and tools will survive the merger?
What’s the communication plan for customers and employees?
How will you align incentives and reporting structures?
Integration planning should begin before signing the LOI. Build a 30–90 day roadmap with key milestones like financial system migration, unified branding, and internal team meetings.
💡 Pro Tip: Double whatever time and cost you initially estimate for integration—you’ll be closer to reality.
4. Evaluate Cultural Alignment
Culture determines whether the deal will succeed long after the spreadsheets balance.
Even the cleanest numbers can’t offset a poor cultural fit.
Ask yourself:
How do they treat customers and employees?
Are their leadership values aligned with yours?
Do they make decisions at a similar pace and with similar transparency?
Spend meaningful time with their team. Observe how they lead meetings and handle conflict. Culture is easier to feel than to measure, but misalignment shows up fast post-close—and it’s expensive to fix.
5. Watch for Red Flags Before You Commit
A competitor business might look strong on paper but hide operational cracks. Be thorough in diligence and skeptical of “easy wins.”
Common red flags include:
Overreliance on the owner: The business depends on one individual’s relationships or expertise.
Customer concentration: One or two clients make up a large portion of revenue.
Inflated EBITDA adjustments: Add-backs that don’t hold up under scrutiny.
Unresolved compliance issues: Pending lawsuits or unpaid taxes.
Cultural toxicity: High turnover or disengaged staff.
Unrealistic synergy claims: “We’ll save $1M next quarter” rarely happens.
If you spot more than two of these, pause. You may be inheriting more problems than profits.
Key Takeaways
Strategic buyers should value deals on pro forma EBITDA, not just seller EBITDA.
Quantify achievable cost synergies and model them conservatively.
A $1M EBITDA business may generate $1.5M under your ownership—cutting your effective multiple from 4x to ~2.6x.
Integration converts paper synergies into real profit.
The right deal can instantly add millions to your enterprise value.
Final Thoughts
Buying a competitor business can be the smartest move you make—or the most expensive mistake. The difference lies in how well you quantify synergies, model valuation, and execute integration.
Breakwater’s buy-side advisory team helps founders identify, evaluate, and integrate acquisitions that create real value—before and after the deal.
👉 Book a consultation with Breakwater’s buy-side advisory team to explore how to value a competitor based on your operational advantages.
FAQs: Valuing a Competitor Business as a Strategic Buyer
How do you value a competitor business as a strategic buyer?
Strategic buyers look beyond standard EBITDA multiples. Instead of paying 4x or 5x based solely on the seller’s numbers, you build a pro forma profit and loss statement showing how your combined operations perform after eliminating redundant costs. This approach gives you a more accurate picture of what the business is worth to you, not just what it’s worth in the market.
What are cost synergies, and why do they matter?
Cost synergies are expense reductions achieved by merging two companies—like eliminating duplicate admin, rent, software, or professional fees. For strategic buyers, these savings flow directly into EBITDA, instantly improving profitability and lowering the effective multiple paid for the deal.
How does a pro forma P&L help with valuation?
A pro forma P&L models the business’s post-acquisition performance. By plugging in your expected cost savings, you can see how $1M in seller EBITDA might become $1.5M for you. That means a $4M purchase price effectively drops from a 4x multiple to about 2.6x.
What’s the difference between a financial buyer and a strategic buyer?
Financial buyers—like private equity firms—evaluate deals based on the company’s standalone performance. Strategic buyers already operate in the same industry and can create value through integration, cross-selling, and shared infrastructure. That advantage allows them to justify higher prices or realize higher returns.
How do synergies impact my enterprise value?
Every dollar of new EBITDA you create increases the value of your entire company. For example, if your firm trades at a 5x multiple and you add $500,000 in EBITDA from synergies, you’ve created $2.5M in enterprise value—often immediately.
What’s a realistic timeline for realizing synergies?
Most cost synergies materialize within 6–12 months after closing, assuming integration is well planned. The key is early execution—align systems, consolidate vendors, and communicate clearly with teams so the savings hit your bottom line quickly.
What are the biggest risks when modeling synergies?
Overestimating savings, underestimating integration costs, or assuming immediate results. Always model conservatively, count only 70% of your projected synergies and allow for one-time transition expenses.
Recommended Reading
For more insights on acquisitions, valuation, and strategic growth, explore these related Breakwater articles:
Should You Sell Your Business to Private Equity?
Understand when PE buyers offer better outcomes than strategic acquirers and how to structure deals that protect founder interests.
What to Do If You Receive an Unsolicited Offer for Your Business
Learn how to evaluate inbound offers, create competitive tension, and avoid leaving money on the table.
How to Sell a Business in Canada: Step-by-Step Guide for 2025
A comprehensive guide covering Canadian M&A processes, timelines, legal considerations, and advisor selection.
Can You Sell an Unprofitable Company? (How to Avoid a Distressed Exit)
Strategies for owners facing thin margins or losses—how to position your business and avoid distressed-sale pitfalls.
📥 Want the Full Guide?
Get access to the complete Million Dollar Business Exit Guide that is packed with tools, checklists, and insights.
Enter your email below for full access:
Join an upcoming webinar!
Whether you’re looking to buy or sell an IT services company, join one of our upcoming events:
Come visit us!